What Borrowers Wished Credit Unions Knew

  • Share:
technology

CUTrendScan

They would rather avoid payday lenders—if they could. But many borrowers who are faced with the need for a fast small-dollar short-term loan don’t have many alternatives. And the soaring number of payday lender locations shows just how frequently financially vulnerable community members are turning to payday services to try and stay afloat.

The payday lending industry experienced an explosive growth over the last two decades. The total number of payday lending stores in the United States eclipsed the number of McDonald’s and Starbucks in 2014 and is today a $41 billion industry. Payday lenders offer an attractive solution to those faced with a financial emergency: get cash in hand, regardless of credit, in mere minutes. For about as long as it takes to order a pizza, borrowers can come into a store and receive a loan without a credit check or extensive documentation. However, that instant gratification can come at a high cost. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) says the average borrower takes out 10 loans each year, often one right after another. CFPB data shows that 70 percent of payday loans are taken out on the same day as a previous loan is repaid.

Payday lenders take advantage of financially vulnerable Americans, especially in rural and minority communities—communities that often already have a credit union present. According to a study in Michigan by the Center for Responsible Lending, payday lenders are strategically placed in communities that are most likely to experience financial shortfalls. The statewide average for payday stores is 5.6 storefronts for every 100,000 people. For communities with a higher population of Latinos, that rises to 6.6 per 100,000. For communities with a higher population of African-Americans, that rises to 7.6 per 100,000. The study also found that rural communities count 7.1 stores per 100,000 people, and communities below 80 percent of a state’s median income have 9.1 stores per 100,000 people.

In 2016 alone, Michigan borrowers lost an estimated $94 million in payday lending fees, with 559 stores statewide. That’s money those borrowers could have used to build an emergency savings fund, pay for car repairs or new clothes for their children without having to take out another loan.

How credit unions can become a better alternative

The majority of consumers (70 percent) believe that payday loans should be more, and better, regulated. Increasingly, borrowers are also clamoring for a more consumer-friendly alternative to traditional financial institutions. According to Pew, eight in ten consumers would prefer small-dollar loans from a bank or credit union over a payday lender, and 92 percent would agree if the loans cost six times less than those of payday lenders.

In the lack of alternatives, be the alternative. Give members a better option.

The advent and dramatic expansion of payday lending in the U.S. is a relatively new phenomenon and should be a wake-up call for credit unions,” said CU Solutions Group President and CEO Dave Adams. “As banks rediscover this lending opportunity, it would be a mistake for credit unions to ignore these trends. Credit unions and their support organizations will need to find creative and disruptive strategies for helping these consumers to make smart banking and borrowing decisions with a complement of financial education.”

CUTrendScan

However, credit unions still have significant challenges when it comes to issuing small-dollar loans. Consumers say that speed, cost, and the certainty of approval are the top factors in choosing where to apply for a loan. For many payday lenders, instant approval is their most attractive feature, despite the staggering cost.

Borrowers also prefer to apply for loans electronically, either through a computer, tablet, or their mobile phone.

CUTrendScan

Risk vs reward for the credit union

As with any new financial product, credit unions have to consider the risks:

When it comes to an automated, online system, two risks credit unions will have to pay careful attention to is the problem of member authentication and underwriting risk. If credit unions are partnering with a fintech firm to create their small-dollar loan solution, they must ensure the fintech has solid member authentication mechanisms that are similar, if not the same, as the mechanisms the credit union already uses for online and mobile banking. In addition, robust underwriting practices reduce the amount of risk the credit union is exposed to for short-term lending, especially as credit unions may wish to look at more than FICO scores.

The first question many credit union leaders will ask is:

Combined, these additional costs may place small-dollar loans out of reach for credit unions that lack the necessary resources.

Fortunately, there are options for credit unions who want to expand their reach without breaking their budget. QCash Financial is one of these alternatives, providing credit unions with an automated, cloud-based, omnichannel lending platform. QCash was created by Washington State Employees Credit Union when the organization discovered a need for a small-dollar loan solution.

Your credit union could learn from their experience:

Using a product like QCash—which was built with credit unions in mind—minimizes the risk and investment of a credit union and has the potential to offer substantial rewards for members and credit unions alike.

  • Share:


« Return to "Trends"
TrendScan logo
<< Back to Articles

Latest Trends

  1. Opportunities and Risks of Banking for Marijuana-Related Businesses
  2. Experience Company Growth and Discovery with Employee-Driven Communication
  3. Should You Still Be Concerned about ADA Website Compliance?
  4. The Member Service Experience
  5. Become a Tax Resource for Members
  6. Don't Get Snagged on ADA Compliance Requirements
  7. Are You Ready to Adopt a Continuous Performance Management System?
  8. Anticipating Change with a Succession Plan
  9. The Role of HR and Hiring Managers in the Candidate Experience
  10. What Is a DDoS Attack and Why Should Credit Unions Be Concerned?
  11. The Planning Process - Improved
  12. The Performance Management Conundrum: Structure vs. Creativity
  13. Consumer Attitudes Toward Digital Advertising
  14. Building a Website with the User in Mind
  15. Is Your Executive Compensation Still Appealing?
  16. Are You Properly Rewarding Your CEO?
  17. What Credit Unions Should Do with Ambiguous ADA Standards
  18. Content Marketing: Well Worth the Effort
  19. 5 Things Credit Unions Can Learn from Cyber Attacks
  20. Your Social Media Accounts Deserve Quality Content
  21. The Quest for a One-Stop Shop Financial App
  22. Credit Unions Could Replace Predatory Lenders
  23. 7 Tax Changes Your Members Need to Know About
  24. Learning Management Systems: What Credit Unions Should Consider
  25. Continuous Performance Management is Disrupting HR
  26. Volunteer and Young Board Members Need Development
  27. Americans’ Lack of Financial Literacy Is an Opportunity for Credit Unions
  28. What’s Hot in Performance Management Technology
  29. Credit Union Compensation: Philosophy or Strategy?
  30. 3 Succession Plans Your Credit Union Needs
  31. The Website Audit Your Credit Union Needs
  32. Cut Through the Noise and Deliver Value Members Want
  33. The Importance of Creating Quality Content
  34. How Useful Are Member Personas for Credit Union Marketing Teams?
  35. Optimizing Websites for Voice: What You Need to Know
  36. Consumer Appetites in Mobile Innovation
  37. Why You Should Invest in an Applicant Tracking System
  38. What Borrowers Wished Credit Unions Knew
  39. Why HR Should Take Advantage of Employee Self Service
  40. Shifts and Trends to Know About in E-Learning
  41. 3 Website Design Trends for 2019
  42. Just How Distracted Are Consumers?
  43. Selling Payments and Wealth Management Services
  44. 3 Key Factors for Creating Good Content
  45. Build Up Membership Through Supportive Savings Programs
  46. Wanted: Apps for Clarification and Simplification
  47. The Win-Win Results of Prize-Linked Savings for Credit Unions and Members
  48. People Analytics: Bringing HR and Data Together
  49. 3 Ways Credit Unions Can Prepare for a Cyber Extortion
  50. Prioritizing the Credit Union Employee Experience
  51. Do You Know Why Payday Loans Are Used so Much?
  52. Popular DDoS Mitigation Methods in 2019
  53. The Credit Union Advantage for the Digital Customer
  54. Preparing a Transparency Communication Plan
  55. The Quickest Way to Understand Enterprise Risk Management (ERM)
  56. Preparing for Compensation Transparency
  57. Is Your CMS the Right Fit?
  58. 4 Steps to Increased Social Media ROI
  59. Keeping Up with Digital Lending Convenience
  60. 6 Factors for Choosing the Right ESS System
  61. Are You Missing Out on the Power of Video?
  62. A Simple Way to Unify Your Marketing Efforts
  63. How Credit Unions Can Formalize the Branding Process
  64. 5 Guideposts to Measure Your Brand Promise Against
  65. 2 Big FinTech Goals for Credit Unions
  66. Making Sure You Have the Right Leaders in the Right Seats
  67. What the C-Suite Wants out of Social Media
  68. Are Your Landing Pages up to Snuff?
  69. The Dream Team for Successful Online Customer Interactions
  70. How to Identify What You Want in an ESS
  71. The Best Compliance Training with New Topics You Will Need
  72. Empowering Employees and HR with the Latest Technology
  73. Credit Unions Can Compete with Shadow Banks
  74. Identifying Marijuana-Related Businesses
  75. Caution: Customers Don't Always Ask for What They Want
  76. Content, Tools, and Channels to Capture Consumer Attention
  77. How Credit Unions Can Embrace Storytelling in Marketing
  78. How to Generate Content with Fewer Resources
  79. If Your Site Isn't Mobile Optimized, You're Losing Out
  80. Protect Your Credit Union with a Website Accessibility Response Plan
  81. Don't Underestimate the Power of Financial Education
  82. Don't Undervalue Your Brand Promise
  83. 3 Factors Impacting Credit Union Compensation Plans
  84. Underestimate the Onboarding Process at Your Peril
  85. Leveraging Social Media for Member Engagement
  86. 3 Brand Promises Credit Unions Can Learn From
  87. Finding the Best Platform for HR Technology
  88. Why You Need ERM in Your Strategic Planning
  89. Serving the Underbanked and Millennials
  90. A Content Management System Will Make Your Life Easier
  91. Enterprise Risk Management — Where to Start
  92. Bankers associations’ opposition to mergers does a disservice to member banks and to consumers
  93. The Quickest Way to Find the Right (and Safest) CMS
  94. Is Your Credit Union Supported by the Four Pillars of Digital Banking?
  95. Omnichannel Delivery: Banking Based On Members
  96. The Easiest Way to Deliver Content for Employee Development
  97. Remaining a Player in the New Home-Buying Experience
  98. You Know You Need an LMS — Now What?
  99. You Might Already Have the Solution to Your Current Talent Competency Gap
  100. Predict the Future of Mortgage Lending with Analytics
  101. Achieving the Golden “Narrative Transport” in Brand Storytelling
  102. The Secret to Future-Proofing Your Organization
  103. The Process of Crafting a Relatable, Moving Brand Story

Related Trends

  1. Remaining a Player in the New Home-Buying Experience
  2. Predict the Future of Mortgage Lending with Analytics
  3. Is Your Credit Union Supported by the Four Pillars of Digital Banking?
  4. Omnichannel Delivery: Banking Based On Members
  5. The Quickest Way to Find the Right (and Safest) CMS
  6. A Content Management System Will Make Your Life Easier
  7. Credit Unions Could Replace Predatory Lenders
  8. 5 Things Credit Unions Can Learn from Cyber Attacks
  9. Do You Know Why Payday Loans Are Used so Much?
  10. What Borrowers Wished Credit Unions Knew
  11. Serving the Underbanked and Millennials
  12. Should You Still Be Concerned about ADA Website Compliance?
  13. Don't Get Snagged on ADA Compliance Requirements
  14. Consumer Appetites in Mobile Innovation
  15. The Quest for a One-Stop Shop Financial App
  16. Wanted: Apps for Clarification and Simplification
  17. What Credit Unions Should Do with Ambiguous ADA Standards
  18. What Is a DDoS Attack and Why Should Credit Unions Be Concerned?
  19. Building a Website with the User in Mind
  20. 3 Ways Credit Unions Can Prepare for a Cyber Extortion
  21. 3 Website Design Trends for 2019
  22. The Credit Union Advantage for the Digital Customer
  23. Optimizing Websites for Voice: What You Need to Know
  24. Is Your CMS the Right Fit?
  25. 2 Big FinTech Goals for Credit Unions
  26. Caution: Customers Don't Always Ask for What They Want
  27. The Website Audit Your Credit Union Needs
  28. Keeping Up with Digital Lending Convenience
  29. Protect Your Credit Union with a Website Accessibility Response Plan
  30. Credit Unions Can Compete with Shadow Banks
  31. Popular DDoS Mitigation Methods in 2019

Industry insights
to your inbox!

Subscribe